Makkah Eye Clinic: Court Strikes Out  N1 Billion Defamation Suit Against WikkiTimes 

A Bauchi State High Court has dismissed a  N1 billion defamation suit filed against WikkiTimes by Albasar International, the owners of Makkah Eye Specialist Hospital, citing the plaintiff’s lack of interest in diligently prosecuting the case.

WikkiTimes had earlier published an investigative report that exposed exploitative billing practices, tax evasion, and retrenching of indigenous staff in the Bauchi-based Makkah Eye Hospital.

Related Posts

Irked by the outcome of the investigation, the hospital sued the outlet, demanding N 1 billion in damages. The investigation also led to direct threats against the Publisher Haruna Mohammed Salisu. In March 2021,  Haruna received an anonymous threat letter slipped into his office. “We know where to get you, even if we didn’t win the case. We know your house, we know your family members, and we know all your movements”, the letter read in part.

Following the investigation, the Christian Blind Mission (CBM), an International Christian Development Organisation working in Nigeria, suspended its partnership programme with hospital, citing credibility concerns.

Achille Chongwa Njinimbot, a compliance manager at the CBM, confirmed to WikkiTimes at the time that organization was concerned after reading the allegations of corruption by the hospital. 

Justice K.N. Hamidu of Bauchi High Court 2 struck out the case, stating that Albasar showed no willingness to pursue the matter. He had earlier awarded ₦40,000 in damages to WikkiTimes and its team due to delays caused by the plaintiff’s absences

However, during the court proceedings, WikkiTimes’ legal counsel, Barrister S.G. Idrees said the hospital repeatedly failed to show commitment to prosecuting the case.

“They were the ones who filed the case, yet on many occasions, we had to push for hearing dates ourselves. Today, once again, they failed to appear in court, and the judge had no option but to strike out the case,” he told WikkiTimes after the ruling.

According to Barrister Idrees, the case is now over although there is the possibility for the hospital to reapply for relisting should they choose to do that but added that “it was unlikely.”

“They’ve shown no real interest in pursuing the matter. If they were confident in their claims, they would have followed through. But it seems clear the case was more of a threat than a pursuit of justice,” he added.

Reacting to the ruling, WikkiTimes Managing Editor, Aminu Adamu, hailed the court’s decision and described the lawsuit as a form of Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation (SLAPP), a tactic used to intimidate critical journalism that holds power to account.

“We commend the court for standing on the side of justice,” Adamu said. “But it is troubling that we had to endure this kind of legal harassment, which was never really about clearing any name but about stifling our resolve to report wrongdoing in society.”

He added that the ruling strengthens the role of independent journalism in holding powerful institutions accountable, particularly in Northern Nigeria where press freedom continues to face growing threats.

WikkiTimes has become a prominent voice in subnational investigative reporting, exposing corruption, abuse of power, and institutional failures across Nigeria’s northern states.

Send us tip

If you or someone you know has a lead, tip or personal experience about this report, our WhatsApp line is open and confidential for a conversation

Latest stories